convent of the sacred heart high school
san francisco, california
volume 12

awards

journalism students do better
updated with a new study!

  rev. 6/2/08 9:50 PM

congratulations to
the broadview 2008-09 staff

editorial board
kelly cheung editor in chief
morgan kendall
editor in chief

lauren jung editor in chief
rebecca kelliher editor in chief
gracie hays a & e editor
ina herlihy news editor
rena hunt photography editor
jovel quelrolo sacred heart editor
sophie gilchrist sports editor

amanda james webmaster

reporters

emily bloch | sarah hegarty | emma herlihy
sara kleopfer | rebecca krasnoff | susie lee
zoë newcomb | isabelle pinard | kendall scullion
colleen scullion | anjali shrestha | nadeen sharara

theresa granucci cartoonist

tracy anne sena, cje adviser

staff2007

the broadview is a member of the National Scholastic Press Association, Columbia Scholastic Press Association and California Newspaper Publishers Association.

AWARDS AND RECOGNITIONS

National Scholastic Press Association rankings

    • All American with five Marks of Distinction (Coverage and Content; Writing and Editing; Photography, Art and Graphics; Layout and Design; and Leadership) for Volume 11, 2006-07.
    • All American with five Marks of Distinction (Coverage and Content; Writing and Editing; Photography, Art and Graphics; Layout and Design; and Leadership) for Volume 10, 2005-06.
    • All American with five Marks of Distinction (Coverage and Content; Writing and Editing; Photography, Art and Graphics; Layout and Design; and Leadership) for Volume 9, 2004-05.
    • All American with four Marks of Distinction (Coverage and Content; Writing and Editing; Photography, Art and Graphics; and Layout and Design) for Volume 8, 2003-04.
    • First Class with three Marks of Distinction (Coverage and Content; Photography, Art and Graphics; Leadership) for Volume 7, 2002-03.
    • First Class with three Marks of Distinction (Coverage and Content; Photography, Art and Graphics; Layout and Design) for Volume 6, 2001-2002.
    • First Class with one Mark of Distinction (Layout and Design) for Volume 5, 2000-2001.
    • First Class for Volume 3, 1999-2000

Northern California Press Women
(An Affiliate of the National Federation of Press Women)
in Sponsorship with The San Francisco Press Club's Junior Scholarship Fund
May 7, 2007

Editorial Cartooning
First Place: Dominique Sheth, “Beverly Hills Rehab: No Vacancy.” May 25, 2007; p. 2.
Second Place: Dominique Sheth, “Oh no, you didn’t.” Nov. 2, 2007. p. 2.
Feature Writing
Second Place: Ina Herlihy “Girls in Uganda appreciate education.” Sept. 21, 2007; p. 9.
Second Place: Lauren Jung, “Mornings with Elsy.” Nov. 2, 2007; p. 5.
Second Place: Rebecca Kelliher, “Summer academics enrich learning.” Feb.15, 2008; p. 7.
Third Place: Rebecca Kelliher, “Alternative gifts benefit earth.” Dec. 14, 2007; p. 4.
Honorable Mention: Rachel Forbes, “Wall art covers district in history, ethnic pride.” May 25, 2007; p. 5.
Honorable Mention: Lauren Jung, Under Pressure: Family life, peers influence choices.”Feb. 15, 2008; p. 5.
Honorable Mention: Rebecca Kelliher, “Procrastinators must help themselves.” Sept. 21, 2007; p. 6. 
Honorable Mention: Mary Slattery, “Vegetarian Diets need supplements.”Nov. 2, 2007; p. 6.
Sports Writing
Honorable Mention: Rebecca Kelliher, “Breathe: Yoga calms nerves through stretches.” Nov. 2, 2007; p. 12.
Column Writing
Honorable Mention: Kelly Cheung, “On another note” (various dates) p. 2. 
Sports Photo
Second Place: Rena Hunt, “Varsity soccer ends season.” May 25, 2007; p. 10.
Review Writing
Third Place: Madalyn Rokisky-Ring, “San Francisco’s vegan treat: Ice cream parlor offers alternative.” March 30, 2007; p. 12.
Second Place: Gracie Hays, “Café offers space for acoustic music.”Nov. 2, 2007; p. 8.
Graphics

Second Place: Tracy Kuwatani and Libby Brittain, “5 ways to save energy.”March 30, 2007; p. 7.
Second Place: Lauren Jung, “How to get your passport.” Feb. 15, 2008; pp. 6-7.
Second Place: Michelle Gantos, “Increased risk of car crash due to various distractions.” March 30, 2007; p. 4.
Environmental Writing
Honorable Mention: Mary Slattery, “City leads in addressing environmental issues.” March 30, 2007; pp. 6-7.
Double-truck Layout
Honorable Mention: Libby Brittain, “Green Revolution.” March 30, 2007; pp. 6-7.

Columbia Scholastic Press Association 2008 Gold Circle Awards

Feature Photograph Portfolio of Work for Newspapers
First Place:
Rena Hunt
.
Comic Cartoons in Newspapers
First Place:
Libby Brittain, “The road to hell is paved with good conversations.” March 30, 2007; p. 2.
Editorial Cartoons in Newspapers
First Place: Libby Brittain, “Pelosi moves in.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 2.
Bar Chart Information Graphics for Newspapers
First Place: Michelle Gantos, “Increased risk of car crash due to various distractions.” March 30, 2007; p. 4.

Journalism Education Association Northern California, January 2008

    Column Writing
    Second Place: Michelle Gantos, "New television show stimulates false feminism." March 30, 2007; p. 5.
    Review Writing
    Third Place: Gracie Hays, "Movers and shakers: Legends, newcomers perform for Pelosi." Feb. 2, 2007.
    Editorial Cartoon
    First Place: Dominique Sheth, "Beverly Hills Rehab." May 25, 2007; p. 2.
    Third Place: Libby Brittain, “Pelosi moves in.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 2.
    Feature Photo
    Third Place: Rena Hunt, “Wyclef Jean encourages audience to wave.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 8.
    Front Page Design
    Second Place: Morgan Kendall, "Convent in the Capital." Feb 2, 2007; p. 1.
    Sports Photo
    First Place: Rena Hunt, "Varsity soccer." May 25, 2007; p. 10.
    Center Spread
    First Place: Kelly Cheung, "Up, up and away." May 25, 2007, pp. 6–7.

Journalism Education Association Write-offs, Philadelphia, Penn., Nov. 11, 2007

Feature Writing Excellent: Lauren Jung
Newspaper New/Feature Photography Excellent: Ina Herlihy
Newswriting Honorable Mention: Morgan Kendall

Editorial Writing Honorable Mention: Kelly Cheung
Sports Writing Honorable Mention: Jovel Queirolo
Editorial Cartooning Honorable Mention: Dominique Sheth
Commentary Writing Honorable Mention: Rebecca Kelliher
Literary Magazine: Layout Honorable Mention: Rachel Forbes

National Scholastic Press Association

Best of Show: Second Place for high school newspapers of 9-12 pages for Volume 12, Issue 2 at the Journalism Education Association / National Scholastic Press Association Fall Convention in Philadelphia, Penn., Nov. 10, 2007.

Best of Show: Fourth Place for high school special edition newspapers, Volume 11, Issue 4 at the Journalism Education Association / National Scholastic Press Association Fall Convention in Philadelphia, Penn., Nov. 10, 2007.

National Federation of Press Women August 2007

Feature Photo
Second Place: Rena Hunt, “The Jersey Boys.” Dec. 4, 2006; p. 4.
Reviews
Honorable Mention: Michelle Gantos, “A flash of San Francisco history, photo exhibition honors centennial of 1906 quake.” Feb. 17, 2006; p. 8.

Northern California Press Women
(An Affiliate of the National Federation of Press Women)
in Sponsorship with The San Francisco Press Club's Junior Scholarship Fund
May 7, 2007

Feature Photo
First Place: Rena Hunt, “The Jersey Boys.” Dec. 4, 2006; p. 4.
Only one first place is awarded in each category; winners also receive $250.
Third Place: Rena Hunt, “Wyclef Jean encourages audience to wave.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 8.
Honorable Mention: Rena Hunt, “Speaker-Elect Nancy Pelosi addresses the audience.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 1.
Graphics
Third Place: Larkin Grant, “Tuning into tube time.” May 19, 2006; p. 8
Third Place: Michelle Gantos and Larkin Grant, “Gossip shifts from celebrities to politics.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 3.
Honorable Mention: Elizabeth Gruber, “Y teens luv txting.” May 19, 2006; p. 3.
News
Second Place: Kelly Cheung, “International labor standards, practices questioned.” Feb 17, 2007; p. 1.
Second Place: Michelle Gantos, “Out of the park.” Nov. 2, 2006; p. 1.
Second Place: Lauren Jung, “Female speakership result of historical struggle.” Feb. 2, 2007; pp. 4–5.
Second Place: Rebecca Kelliher, “Defense class aids women.” Feb. 16, 2007; p. 11.
Second Place: Mary Slattery, “Toxic ingredients in personal products can have harmful effects.” May 19, 2006; p. 1.
Third Place: Morgan Kendall and Rachel Forbes, “‘Too thin’ models spark changes.” Nov. 2, 2006; p. 1.
Opinion
Second Place: Michelle Gantos, “Sexuality does not determine the quality of a parent.” April 7, 2006; p. 3.
Third Place: Elizabeth Moore, “Future leaders needed in time of dissatisfied nation.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 3.
Third Place: Elizabeth Moore, “Massive homework load stifles learning.” Nov. 2, 2006; p. 3.
Honorable Mention: Michelle Gantos, “Gossip shifts from celebrities to politics.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 3.
Reviews
First Place: Michelle Gantos, “A flash of San Francisco history, photo exhibition honors centennial of 1906 quake.” Feb. 17, 2006; p. 8.
Only one first place is awarded in each category; winners also receive $250.
Honorable Mention: Gracie Hays, “Movers and shakers: Legends, newcomers perform for Pelosi.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 8.
Single Page Layout
Third Place: Larkin Grant, “Tuning into the tube.” May 19, 2006; p. 8.           
Honorable Mention: Tanaya Macheel, “Biking in the city.” May 19, 2006; p. 12.
Environmental
Third Place: Kelly Cheung, “Locally grown food may improve environment.” Feb. 17, 2007; p. 1.
Cartooning
Honorable Mention: Libby Brittain, “Pelosi moves in.” Feb. 2, 2007; p. 2.
Sports Photo
Second Place: Libby Brittain, “Senior guard Jen Hum-Traverso.” April 7, 2006
; p. 10.

Journalism Education Association Northern California, January 2007

    Centerspread
    First Place: Libby Brittain & Lara Jordan, "You are what you eat." Oct. 28, 2005.
    Editorial Cartoon
    Third Place: Christina Hsu, "Go back to sleep, dear." Dec. 15, 2005.
    Editorial Writing
    First Place: Michelle Gantos, "Consumerism, manic shoppers distort theme of generosity." Dec. 15, 2005.
    Feature Story
    Second Place: Elizabeth Moore.
    Infographic Design

    First Place: Christina Hsu & Rachel Forbes, "Five simple rules of curling." Feb. 14, 2006.
    News Story
    Second Place: Mary Slattery, "Toxic ingredients in personal products can have harmful effects." May 19, 2006.
    Photo Illustration
    Third Place: Lara Jordan, "A lesson in etiquette. " Dec. 15, 2005.
    Sports Photo
    First Place: Libby Brittain, "Senior guard Jen Hum-Traverso." April 7, 2006.

Journalism Education Association Write-offs, Nashville, Tenn., Nov. 12, 2006

Copy Editing Superior: Libby Brittain
Newswriting Honorable Mention: Morgan Kendall

Two-weeks' work (photography) Honorable Mention: Rena Hunt

2006 NSPA / Newspaper Association of America Foundation Pacemaker Winner Nov. 11 in Nashville, Tenn.

2006 NSPA / Newspaper Association of America Foundation Pacemaker Finalist

National Federation of Press Women, Sept. 9, 2006

Graphics Honorable Mention Christina Hsu: “You are what you eat.” Oct. 28, 2005, pp. 6-7.

Northern California Press Women
(An Affiliate of the National Federation of Press Women)
in Sponsorship with The San Francisco Press Club,
May 23, 2006

Graphics First place Christina Hsu: “You are what you eat”
Only one first place is awarded in each category; winners also receive $500
Second place Christina Hsu: “Deciding a murderer’s fate”
Second place Christina Hsu: “5 simple rules of curling”
Second place Elizabeth Moore: “Brainy bunch”
Third place Christina Hsu: “Recycling old phones can help save lives”
Editorial Second place Elizabeth Moore: “Muni fares must be increased”
Opinion Second place Elizabeth Moore: “DeYoung design is not up to par”
News Honorable mention Morgan Kendall: “Local pet shelter rescues unwanted cats and dogs”
Feature Third place: Elizabeth Moore: “Sacred Heart Uganda schools achieve educational success”
Single Page Layout Third place Michelle Gantos: “The new ultimate reference guide”
Garretson Environmental Award Third place Elizabeth Moore: “Not recycling water bottles can cause harm to the environment”

Journalism Education Association Write-offs in San Francisco, April 23, 2006

Copy Editing Excellent: Libby Brittain
Newswriting Honorable Mention: Morgan Kendall

Feature Writing Honorable Mention: Michelle Gantos

National Scholastic Press Association

Best of Show: Sixth Place for high school newspapers of 9-12 pages for Volume 10, Issue 5 at the Journalism Education Association / National Scholastic Press Association Spring Convention in San Francisco, April 22, 2006.

Columbia Scholastic Press Association 2006 Silver Crown for Volume 9.

Columbia Scholastic Press Association 2006 Gold Circle Awards

Personal Opinion: Off-Campus Issues Certificate of Merit: Elizabeth Moore, “Some pets are too dangerous,” Sept. 23, 2005, p. 5.
In-Depth News/Feature Story Certificate of Merit: Elizabeth Moore, “Do you know what it means to miss New Orleans?” Sept. 23, 2005, pp. 6–7.
Art/Illustration: portfolio of work Certificate of Merit: Kellyn Planteen, Volume 9, 2004–05.

Journalism Education Association Write-offs in Chicago, Nov. 13, 2005

Newswriting Excellent: Morgan Kendall
Editorial Writing Honorable Mention: Michelle Gantos

National Scholastic Press Association

Best of Show: Tenth Place for high school newspapers of 9-12 pages for Volume 10, Issue 2 at the Journalism Education Association / National Scholastic Press Association Fall Convention in Chicago, Nov. 12, 2005.

2005 NSPA / Newspaper Association of America Foundation Pacemaker Finalist
Winners are selected by a panel from the Chicago Tribune.

Northern California High School Newspaper Journalism Awards 
Sponsored by The Sacramento Bee Oct. 8, 2005 | Sacramento

Staff  editorial  First place: Elizabeth Moore, “Muni fares must be increased.” 
Review
  Third place: Vivian Chau “SF Best.”
Graphic  Third place: Kellyn Planteen
Editorial  Cartoon Second place: Kellyn Planteen

Northern California Press Women
(An Affiliate of the National Federation of Press Women)
in Sponsorship with The San Francisco Press Club, May 18, 2005

Garretson Environmental Award Second Place: Kyle Cannon: "Bringing back Hetch Hetchy."
Editorial Honorable Mention: Michelle Gantos: "Wristbands turn political."
Opinion Honorable Mention: Caroline Corbitt: "It's time to lose poor posture and speech habits."
News Second Place: Caroline Corbitt: "State budget may curb UC admissions."
Column
Second Place: Vivian Chau: "San Francisco Best."
Reviews
Third Place: Vivian Chau: "Flavorable Asian meal fills hungry stomachs."
Single Page Layout Honorable Mention: Ashly-Nikkole Davis: "News 1."
Sports Photo
Second Place: Elizabeth Moore: "Captain Tina de Tienne hugs teammate."
Graphics
Third Place: Nicole Gantos: "How to get a driver's license."
Third Place: Nicole Gantos: "The do's and don'ts of driving."
Third Place: Nicole Gantos: "iPod or CD?"
Honorable Mention: Vivian Chau: "Chemical imbalance."
Honorable Mention: Michelle Gantos: "How time is spend on the new SAT."

National Scholastic Press Association

Best of Show: Second Place for high school newspapers of 9-12 pages for Volume 9, Issue 5 at the Journalism Education Association / National Scholastic Press Association Spring Convention in Seattle, April 9, 2005.

Best of Show: Third Place for high school newspapers of 9-12 pages for Volume 9, Issue 2 at the Journalism Education Association / National Scholastic Press Association Fall Convention in Atlanta, Nov. 20, 2004.

Journalism Education Association Write-offs, in Atlanta, November 2004

Newswriting Honorable Mention: Kyle Cannon
Editorial Writing Honorable Mention: Caroline Corbitt
Sports Writing Honorable Mention: Abby Miller
Editorial Cartooning Excellent: Kellyn Planteen
YB Copy/Caption: Academics Superior: Ashly-Nikkole Davis

Northern California Press Women
(An Affiliate of the National Federation of Press Women)
, May 8, 2004

Garretson Environmental Award
First Place:
Elizabeth Moore: "Something's really fishy." Dec.18, 2003.
Sports Photography
First Place:
Michelle Gantos: "Sailing into popularity." Feb. 13, 2004.
Only one first place is awarded in each category; winners also receive $250
Editorial
Second Place: Caroline Corbitt: "Test revisions are increasingly partial."
Second Place:
Anne Heminger: "Marriage is a constitutional right."
News
Second Place: Caroline Corbitt: "Discrimination: It's not black and white"
Column

Third Place:
Abby Miller: "The ball drops here."
Sports
Second Place: Michelle Gantos: "Sailing into popularity."
Honorable Mention: Nicole Gantos: "Casey Haggerman."
Honorable Mention: Juliana Rotter: "Varsity basketball team prepares for daunting post-season games."
Reviews

Second Place: Vivian Chau: "Pecan pie."
Third Place: Vivian Chau: "Boba tea."
Honorable Mention: Laurel Lang: "People, places & performances."
Single Page Layout
Honorable Mention: Vivian Chau: "Spiritual paths."
Honorable Mention: Kyle Cannon: "Seniors say goodbye."
Honorable Mention: Elizabeth Moore: "It's in the bag."
Feature Photo

Second Place: Kyle Cannon: "Game breaks more than ice."
Second Place: Jetty-Jane Connor: "Spiritual paths."
Second Place: Juliana Rotter: "Lion dancers wow school community."

National Scholastic Press Association

Best of Show: Fifth Place for high school newspapers of 9-12 pages for Volume 8, Issue 5 at the Journalism Education Association / National Scholastic Press Association Spring Convention in San Diego, April 3, 2004.

Journalism Education Association Write-offs, Washington, D.C., November 2003

Newswriting Honorable Mention: Caroline Corbitt
Sports Writing Honorable Mention: Juliana Rotter
YB Copy/Caption: Academics Honorable Mention: Vivian Chau

National Scholastic Press Association

Picture of the Year: Sports Photography (Co-sponsored with the National Press Photographers Association)
Third Place: Elizabeth Franczak for postgame girls' basketball on page 1 in the April 2003 edition. Sept. 16, 2003.

An Opinion page from Volume 6 is featured in Best of the High School Press 9. National Scholastic Press Association, 2003.

Best of Show: Seventh Place for high school newspapers of 12 pages or less for Volume 7, Issue 2 at the Journalism Education Association / National Scholastic Press Association Fall Convention in Dallas, November 2002.

2003 Northern California High School Newspaper Journalism Awards
Co-sponsored by The Sacramento Bee, announced during Capital Journalism Day, Oct. 18, 2003, at California State University, Sacramento

Sports story Honorable Mention: Tatiana Natzke
Single-page layout Honorable Mention: Anne Heminger

Center for Integration and Improvement of Journalism
Cosponsored by the Independent Press Association

Best Package for a Teens and Alcohol spread "Dealing with Drinking," Volume 7, Issue 5. Package design by Caroline Corbitt.

Northern California Press Women
(An affiliate of the National Federation of Press Women)
2003 High School Journalism Contest

Editorial
Honorable Mention: Caroline Corbitt, “Contraception education encourages teens”
Honorable Mention: Amanda Coffee, “Teen urban driving myth turns out to be fact”
Feature Photo
Second Place: Kyle Cannon, “Tourists Gather at Ground Zero”
Reviews
Second Place: Vivian Chau, “Japantown offers unique market treats”
Second Place: Amanda Coffee and Nicole Gantos, “Tiburon makes fun escape from city”

Layout
Third Place: Anne Heminger, “Shopping with Liz

Journalism Education Association Write-offs, Dallas, 2002

Sports Writing Excellent: Kyle Cannon
Feature Writing Honorable Mention: Elizabeth Franczak

American Society of Newspaper Editors
How high school papers covered 9/11

Journalism Education Association Write-offs, Boston, 2001

Newswriting Honorable Mention: Megan Seely

>back to top


JOURNALISM STUDENTS DO BETTER

Students who work on a newspaper or yearbook staff in high school do better in high school and college than students with no journalism experience, according to a 1994 study. The study found  

  • high school students who were members of a journalism staff had higher grade-point-averages in English, social studies, math, and science than students who were not members of a journalism staff.
  • high school students who were members of a journalism staff scored in the 81st percentile in the English portion of the ACT test. High school students who were not members of a journalism staff scored in the 69th percentile. Students with journalism staff experience also did better on the social studies and math portions of the test.
  • high school students who were members of a journalism staff reported that high school journalism classes developed their development of English skills better than any other course including English courses.
  • high school students who were members of a journalism staff were more involved in extracurricular activities such as clubs, student government and were elected captain of a team more often than students who were not members of a journalism staff. They were also more likely to take an advanced English placement course and to volunteer in the community.
  • college students who were members of a high school journalism staff had higher grade-point averages in their first college English courses than students who were not members of a high school journalism staff.
  • college students who were members of a high school journalism staff had higher overall grade-point averages than students who were not members of a high school journalism staff.
  • college students who were members of a high school journalism staff wrote better on the ACT COMP (College Outcome Measures Test) than students who were not members of a high school journalism staff.1

1 Dvorak, Jack and others. Journalism Kids Do Better.

>back to top